When investing in a quality leather jacket, two names often rise to the top, representing distinct philosophies and styles: AllSaints and Schott NYC. Both are titans in the leather jacket world, yet they offer vastly different experiences. AllSaints brings modern, fashion forward East London cool, while Schott NYC embodies classic American rebellion and rugged heritage.

Choosing between them can be tough. Are you drawn to contemporary slim fits and softer leathers, or timeless, durable designs built to last a lifetime (and then some)? This comparison will break down the key differences in style, quality, fit, and philosophy to help you decide which iconic brand aligns best with your personal style and needs.

AllSaints: Modern Edge, Fashion Focus

Founded in London in 1994, AllSaints quickly became known for its moody color palettes, vintage inspired details, and distinctly contemporary, often slim fitting silhouettes. Their leather jackets are central to their brand identity.

• Aesthetic: Edgy, modern, urban cool. Often features washed or treated leathers for a slightly worn in look from day one. Think rock 'n' roll meets contemporary fashion.
• Signature Styles: Models like the Balfern, Dalby, and Elmore biker jackets are brand staples, known for their slim arms, often asymmetrical zips, and polished hardware.
• Leather Type: Primarily uses softer leathers like lambskin and sheepskin, prioritizing a comfortable, broken in feel and drape right off the rack.
• Fit: Generally slim and contemporary. Jackets are designed to fit close to the body, particularly through the sleeves and shoulders. Sizing up is sometimes necessary for layering.
• Construction: Well constructed for fashion wear, focusing on style and immediate comfort over heavy duty, protective construction.

Caption: AllSaints jackets are known for their modern, slim silhouettes and fashion-forward details.

Schott NYC: Heritage, Durability, American Icon

Schott NYC is steeped in history. Founded in New York City in 1913, they invented the motorcycle jacket, the iconic Perfecto, in 1928. Their legacy is built on producing incredibly durable outerwear for motorcyclists, military personnel, and rebels.

• Aesthetic: Classic American workwear and motorcycle heritage. Timeless, rugged, and built for function first, with style developing organically from that.
• Signature Styles: The legendary Perfecto jacket (models like the 613 'One Star' or 618) is their cornerstone. They also offer classic A-2 bomber jackets, racer jackets, and car coats.
• Leather Type: Often uses heavier, tougher leathers like steerhide and cowhide, known for their stiffness initially but incredible durability and potential to mold to the wearer over time. Some models use softer leathers too.
• Fit: Traditionally a more classic, sometimes boxier American fit, designed for layering and movement (especially older models). Newer collections may offer slimmer options, but the core fit is less constricting than AllSaints.
• Construction: Built like tanks. Focus is on extreme durability, heavy duty hardware, and construction techniques designed to withstand serious wear and tear. Many are still made in the USA.

Caption: Schott NYC's Perfecto embodies timeless American style and rugged durability.

Head-to-Head Comparison

Primary Vibe

• AllSaints: Modern, Fashion-Forward, Edgy
• Schott NYC: Classic, Heritage, Rugged, Timeless

Typical Leather

• AllSaints: Lambskin, Sheepskin (Softer, Lighter)
• Schott NYC: Steerhide, Cowhide (Tougher, Heavier)

Break-in Period

• AllSaints: Minimal to None
• Schott NYC: Significant (Especially Steerhide)

Common Fit

• AllSaints: Slim, Contemporary
• Schott NYC: Classic American, Roomier (Can Vary)

Construction

• AllSaints: Fashion-Focused
• Schott NYC: Durability-Focused, Heavy-Duty

Origin

• AllSaints: UK Brand, Global Manufacturing
• Schott NYC: US Brand, Significant USA Manufacturing

Price Range

• AllSaints: Premium Fashion Pricing
• Schott NYC: Premium Heritage/Workwear Pricing (Similar)

Iconic Model

• AllSaints: Balfern / Dalby Biker
• Schott NYC: Perfecto Motorcycle Jacket

Caption: The leather choice significantly impacts the feel and break-in: AllSaints often uses softer skins, while Schott is famed for tough hides.

Which Brand Is Right For You?

Choose AllSaints if:

• You prioritize a modern, slim fitting silhouette.
• You prefer softer leather that feels broken in immediately.
• Your primary use is fashion and everyday wear, not heavy duty protection.
• You like contemporary details and a polished, edgy look.

Choose Schott NYC if:

• You value timeless, heritage design with a rich history.
• You want exceptional durability and a jacket that will likely outlive you.
• You don't mind (or even enjoy) breaking in tougher leather.
• You prefer a classic American fit or need room for layering.
• Made in USA heritage is important to you.

The Verdict: Two Paths to Leather Jacket Excellence

Neither AllSaints nor Schott NYC is objectively "better"; they simply cater to different desires. AllSaints offers instant gratification with its fashion forward designs and soft leathers, perfect for the style conscious urbanite. Schott NYC provides a piece of American history, a rugged companion built to endure decades of wear and develop unique character along the way.

Your choice depends on whether you seek contemporary edge or timeless heritage, immediate comfort or long term patina. Both brands represent significant investments, but understanding their core differences ensures you invest in the leather jacket titan that truly speaks to your style.

Which brand resonates more with you, AllSaints or Schott NYC? Share your preference or experiences in the comments below! Thinking about leather types? Refresh your knowledge with our guide on identifying high quality leather.